Let Congress do its duty

editorial cartoon by Yasuyuki Nagasawa
editorial cartoon by Yasuyuki Nagasawa

Who cares if you were the President of the United States and led the Union to victory in the Civil War? According to the media, you enjoy your booze just a little too much, Ulysses S. Grant, and therefore you are not fit to hold public office.

So what makes a qualified public servant—one’s personal life or one’s life work? Henry Foster’s name may soon join the list of presidential nominees who have been struck down before their actual Congressional confirmation hearings due to the meddling of the media and public which has tainted the appointment process.

Foster, like Zoe Baird and Lani Guinier before him, has been put on trial by public opinion and not given the opportunity to face the Congress that is supposed to appoint them.

The Campus Times believes the leakage of information with the intent of harming a nominee’s image is hindering the duty Congress was set forth to do. Congress has been appointed by voters to approve or disapprove of presidential nominees. Its decision should be objective and fair, however recent cases are eroding this process.

Baird withdrew as Clinton’s nominee for Attorney General in January 1993 after the media and public expressed disdain toward her employment of two illegal Peruvian immigrants. Her qualifications as Attorney General were overshadowed by her relationship with the two immigrants. Frustrated with negative public opinion, Baird removed herself from the candidacy.

After Baird, Guinier, possible appointee as the head of the Justice Department’s Civil Rights Division, became the next victim. Guinier was labeled as an extremist and a “quota queen” due to articles she had written supporting cumulative voting arrangements and a minority veto. Both of these proposals were intended to keep a majority from using too much power. One might even consider this a type of check and balance the Constitution aims for. However, Guinier’s nomination was pulled before she could face her peers due to lack of Senate support.

Clinton seems to have hit another wall with his nomination of Foster to the office of Surgeon General. The issue has become the number of abortions Foster has performed instead of his potential as Surgeon General. In an interview Foster claimed the number was less than 12. However, the National Right to Life Committee reported that the number was closer to 700. The public and media focused on the abortion issue until the accurate number of 94 procedures was calculated by Foster’s records. The time and energy used to get the accurate number of abortions would have been in better use if officials would have taken precedence to Foster’s qualifications for the position.

The exploitation of faults in nominee’s lives should not infringe on the candidate’s right to a fair and objective Congressional hearing. It is the duty of Congress to put possible appointees on trial. The people have put their input into the decision by voting on the individual who will represent their views. It is time to let Congress do the job it was established to do and let nominees receive the benefit of the doubt they deserve.

Other Stories

Unsigned editorials represent the opinion of the Campus Times Editorial Board.

Yasuyuki Nagasawa (above) and Lisa Scott are the two artists whose ideas of painting a mural last spring were snubbed due to controversy on where to paint it. The wall behind Nagasawa was the original site for the mural. / photo by Veero Der-Karabetian
Yasuyuki Nagasawa
Other Stories
Previous article
Next article

Latest Stories

Related articles

RESTRICT Act would result in the ban of TikTok, other apps

U.S. senators Mark R. Warner and John Thune proposed the Restricting the Emergence of Security Threats that Risk Information and Communications Technology Act on March 7. If the bill were to pass, it would give the government the power to act against technological companies if they pose a national security threat to Americans.

LVPD concealed carry weapon applications cause a divide

The city of La Verne's recently announced concealed weapons permit policy has drawn a threat of legal action over the cost of the permits.

Legislation would teach high school students financial literacy

An Assembly Bill, that would require all California high school students to take a full-year course in personal finance before graduating, was introduced Feb. 15, by California State Assemblymember Kevin McCarty, D-Sacramento. 

Legislation would ban the removal of western Joshua trees

A law to protect the Western Joshua Tree, a native desert plant, and make it illegal to import, export, sell, or remove the species without a state authorization was first introduced on February 7th by California Governor Gavin Newsom.