Tucker gets lethal injection

Capital punishment. Should the government have the right to take a human’s life for a crime or should the criminal’s life be spared and sentenced to jail time?

The answer for the state of Texas has been to not hesitate, but rather to impose the sentence on an almost regular basis, 144 times in the Lone Star State since 1976, when the Supreme Court reinstated capital punishment, more than any other state in the United States. So when Karla Faye Tucker was on death row in Texas, her fate was sealed.

According to the Chicago Tribune, in 1983, Tucker along with her boyfriend, Danny Garrett, broke into the Houston apartment of Jerry Dean, who was with the company of Deborah Thornton asleep in bed. Burglary was Tucker’s first idea, but she ended up using a pickax on both Dean and Thornton in a murder-frenzy fueled by drugs.

On Tuesday, Tucker paid the ultimate price for her crime-death by lethal injection. But Tucker stands for much more than just an end to the crime she committed. She became the first woman in the state of Texas to be executed since the Civil War and only the second woman (Velma Barfield in North Carolina was the first woman to be put to death since the Supreme Court ruling to reinstate the death penalty in 1976) to be put to death.

This case certainly re-opened the debate on whether or not capital punishment should continue in America. What made this into a media frenzy and so high profile was that Tucker was a woman. However, that fact should not be a determining factor in deciding whether or not to impose capital punishment.

The issue of capital punishment is a hard subject to deal with. On one side of the coin, many victim’s families want closure, or revenge for lack of a better term.

“I want to say to every victim in the world, ‘Demand this; this is your right.’ Fourteen and a half years ago, Karla Faye Tucker exploded my family. Fourteen and half years later, she brought my family back together … We’ll begin tomorrow without the name Karla Faye Tucker stuck in our face every day,” said Richard Thornton, Deborah Thornton’s husband, after the execution on Tuesday.

Richard Thornton is right because Tucker’s actions could not be ignored by the state. And if the state had let Tucker off with just a stiff sentence, the example to society is that of “Don’t kill. But if you do, we won’t sentence you to death, maybe just a long time in jail.” If the consequence of killing someone is only jail time, does this scare future offenders to remain good?

But at the same time, who are we to say who lives and who dies?

Maybe Tucker did find the Lord as she claims to have done. Maybe Tucker did change her ways to a point where she was sane. Pope John Paul II felt Tucker had changed, sending a message to Texas Gov. George W. Bush asking him to spare Tucker’s life.

But Bush’s decision was to ignore the message by Pope John Paul II and the rest of the Tucker supporters and let the execution follow through as planned.

Tucker was a woman who killed and then learned from her mistake, finding peace in the Lord through Christianity. But she may have done that in a final plea to spare her life, knowing religion was her last attempt to live.

Although Tucker was killed, she did accomplish a rebirth, at least in her mind. Maybe for both sides this was best or maybe it was not. In any event, the answer to the question of the capital punishment debate, in Texas’ view, is the highest form of punishment. No matter what changes Tucker went through, the crime had already been committed, and regardless of her being a woman, her punishment of death for the crime, double murder, she committed.

Other Stories

Unsigned editorials represent the opinion of the Campus Times Editorial Board.

Latest Stories

Related articles

Commentary: Menendez brothers deserve clemency

I am a strong believer that Erik and Lyle Menendez should be released from prison and living out their lives at home with their families – following their well-known case. 

Research shows impact of juvenile court system

Sharon Davis, professor of sociology, talks about the issues surrounding the juvenile court system and low income families on Tuesday at the weekly faculty lecture series held in the Campus Center Ballroom.

Claudette Colvin is unsung hero for civil rights movement

Claudette Colvin, an activist and pioneer in the civil rights movement, refused to give up her seat months before Rosa Parks refused hers. She was 15 at the time.

L.A. marijuana cases set to be dismissed

According to Los Angeles County District Attorney George Gascón, Los Angeles County is set to dismiss about 60,000 marijuana convictions in the upcoming months. The final step is to consider damages caused by narcotics enforcements before California voted to decriminalize marijuana.