
Marina Bravo
Arts Editor
Karen Beavers, research and instructional librarian, presented the different research strategies she explored and learned during her sabbatical Tuesday as part of the faculty lecture series.
Beavers’ presentation titled “How do I know which article to choose?” explored different methods professors can use to present to students when finding academic and scholarly articles.
About 25 faculty members and students attended the talk on Zoom and in person the Quay Davis Executive Board Room.
Beavers was introduced by Megan Granquist, professor of kinesiology.
“Researching is a process,” Beavers said. “The relevance (of a source) is not just the objective or if it is the perfect source, it is figuring out and making sure it answers what you are representing in your research.”
Beavers went on to share various techniques and strategies that professors can use to guide their students in the research process and even use for their own research.
These methods included Currency, Relevance, Authority, Accuracy and Purpose, or CRAAP, developed at Cal State Chico; Evaluating Resources developed at UC-Berkeley ; and Background Sources, Exhibit sources, Argument sources, and Theory or Method sources, BEAT or BEAM, developed by Joseph Bizup.
Each strategy helps one figure out how to use sources in arguments and how to find the best articles to back up their arguments, Beavers explained.
Along with the various approaches, Beavers also went into depth on how to navigate the new search engines on online databases like JSTOR and ProQuest.
Beavers reminded her audience that this new AI era in a digital age is inevitable.
As much as it scares her, as much as she dislikes it, AI is here to stay, Beavers said.
Marcia Godwin, associate dean and professor of public administration, talked about how she is uneasy about using some online databases.
“I am on the fence about even ProQuest,” Godwin said. “They seem to be taking our work to train these machines to have the answers.”
Beavers reminded that even the “trustworthy” online databases have developed AI tool options that are presented in such a “human” way and that is alone a big problem.
“We can see that the AI systems use the terms ‘responsible’ and ‘reliable’,” Beavers said. “They promise to help the students craft their searches and construct their searches. In ProQuest, as you search, it prompts you with possible related terms that are generated by AI.”
Beavers reminded the audience that even though it’s an uncomfortable topic, educators need to stay on top of it and learn with the system so they can better assist their students in differentiating among AI tools when they come across them.
“It is interesting that even the legendary JSTOR is susceptible to AI,” said Kenneth Marcus, professor of history.
Professor of Political Science Jason Neidleman shared his own concerns with AI and reminded the group about the value of humanity.
“AI is coming and normalizing what might be eccentric in your search,” Neidleman said. “And it is the eccentricity of your search that makes it valuable. AI by definition cannot do that because it is trained on things that people have already said.”
Beavers acknowledged that AI is scary, however, students are using these tools and it is important to understand them in order to redirect.
Her approach to redirection with students is to give the pen back to the writer. She wants to empower the students and remind them that when looking for sources, they are the ones who know their research topic best.
“You are the person who knows about your topic,” Beavers said. “I think sometimes the worry about getting a perfect set of sources so their professors won’t fail them does get in the way. There is really so much more that should go into the research process.”
Marina Bravo can be reached at marina.bravo@laverne.edu.
Marina Bravo is a senior communications major with a concentration in public relations. She is arts editor and a staff photographer for the Campus Times, and has previously served as a staff writer and photographer for the Campus Times and La Verne Magazine. She enjoys going to live shows and everything spooky.


