Music Review: Conformists need not apply

John Patrick
LV Life Editor

For those who are tired of cookie cutter music that is more about pleasing the fashion-conscious adolescent masses than actually coming close to intelligent artistic expression, the Decemberists’ fourth album, “Picaresque,” is an oasis in the wasteland.

Like other albums by this Portland, Oregon based band, “Picaresque” is a monument to their own ethos—an amalgamation of musical styles that includes indy sensibilities, sea shanties, waltzes and eastern European flair to create a sound that is both unique and enjoyable.

But beyond catchy tunes with great hooks, the Decemberists display two characteristics that set them further apart from today’s mainstream music scene. The first is their ability to tell stories through song. Unlike so many of today’s musicians who glorify sexuality and materialism, the Decemberists create heartfelt music full of whimsical characters. Such is the case of “The Mariner’s Revenge Song,” which is about a young man who sets sail with a privateer to track down and deliver revenge upon a man who had wronged his family.

The second of the Decemberists defining quirks goes a long way to propping up the first.

It is lead singer and songwriter Colin Meloy’s ability to wield a wide and eccentric vocabulary. Evident in the album’s title, this ability makes songs like “Infanta,” “The Bagman’s Gambit,” “The Sporting Life” and “The Mariner’s Revenge Song” all the more enjoyable.

As if this weren’t enough, the technical ability of the band members is evident as they play a whole array of instruments. In addition to the bass, drums and guitars, violins, tam-tams, shofars, accordions and a whole host of other instruments are used to create the Decemberists’ signature sound.

All in all, this album does not disappoint. Though I wouldn’t recommend it to those who are looking for mainstream, corporate schlock, it should be deeply satisfying for those who try to steer clear of America’s top 40.

John Patrick can be reached at

Other Stories

Journalism operations manager at the University of La Verne. Production manager and business manager of the Campus Times.

Latest Stories

Related articles

Music Review: Lana Del Rey enters new era with experimental album

As melancholic as Lana Del Rey’s music always is, her newest album “Did You Know That There’s a Tunnel Under Ocean Boulevard?”, released in March, is the most emotional and personal to date. 

Music Review: ‘Dance Fever’ is a musical ode to Greek mythology

Florence + The Machine’s new album “Dance Fever,” released on May 13, is a boisterous journey about the pent-up energy from the pandemic through a fairytale-like production.

Music Review: Charli XCX creates pop perfection with ‘Crash’

With clear 1980s and early 2000s influences, Charli XCX proves that she is one of the main pop girls and a veteran songwriter with her sell-out album “Crash,” released on March 18.

Music Review: Quarantine fuels Charli XCX’s creativity in ‘how i’m feeling now’

Pop has experienced a resurgence in creativity with Charli XCX at the forefront. In “how i’m feeling now,” one of her most interactive releases, Charli XCX delivers her most honest record yet.